The author of “For better health, pay Perry no mind” is
targeting the politically active citizens of Texas in an effort to reach the
state legislature. Although he or she seems to have done their fair share of research,
there is no mention of the authors name, occupation, or political experience in
this editorial leading to no inherent trust in this opinion written. The author bases his argument on logos; relying
on numbers to forward his case that the state of Texas should cooperate with
the national government in health insurance reform. He notes the six million uninsured Texans and
the opportunity to insure 2.3 million low-income Texans by 2023 if Medicaid is
expanded. While the numbers do not lie
and there is clearly a health care issue in the state, the author
underestimates the costs this reform would place on the government and in turn
the citizens of Texas. He supplies the
number of a $15.6 billion burden on the government of Texas; quite a large
burden considering the state government’s current budget issues and
unwillingness to further tax it’s citizens. The author is correct in suggesting
a need for change in the health care system of Texas, but I believe the Patient
Protection and Affordable Care Act is not the method of change this state needs
and I support Rick Perry’s decision not to expand Medicaid or set up a health
insurance exchange without first securing its financing.
No comments:
Post a Comment